I had to group with Fatherkline.
With his reputation and having never grouped with him before, I needed to know for myself. So last night, I saw a raid group for Reavers Fate up. Figuring I wasn't going to complete the quest and it would give me plenty of opportunity to take some screen shot to document the event... I joined.
A few things before I tell the story... While we were waiting for group to fill he made a racial slur, and claimed he could solo heal Reavers and was a better healer when he was drunk.
So, people must have wanted to fuck with him because we went from a full group and as soon as we started to go in (on elite) 3 members bailed. We head in and to the left hugging the wall, oh did I forget to mention buffing stage? Nope, because there wasn't one. Once we were there Fatherkline decides he is going to help tank Stormreaver.

Please note in the pic the lack of buffs, (there was a bit of arcane buffage but that had worn off) The lack of Fatherkline using any SP on anything, and the fact that he is over there with the tank, (Stormreaver is to the right) and in group him saying he is going to help tank, being clearly told he is needed to heal, and he ignoring it.
Here is another screen shot about 30 seconds earlier. Best screen shots I have of the situation.