BDR factors in crits and you have said (and implied) that it doesn't multiple times including in this post I quoted. So you don't understand it's formula or you have a poor understanding of it's formula based on your own posts. IMO you're saying it's useless because you have an incomplete understanding of it. I am saying it's a another data point, no more or less useful than the formula it's based on. I don't use BDR to decided which weapon to use, I don't use Enhancement bonus to decide what weapon to use. By the same token I also don't ignore Enhancement bonus, nor will I call it useless just because I don't base weapon choices on it. It's a data point.

Your attacks on it and calling anyone that looks at it as a data point a "newbie" have an unhealthy ring of fervent belief, but with no specific math to back them up, they just end up sounding like you're demonizing something you have an incomplete understanding of.