Rubbinns wrote on Jul 30
th, 2020 at 4:31pm:
The difference is going to be a lot higher than 5k~ dps just in LD. And you are behind in bursts from not being able to Through the Mists swap.
The poison dice are not that great because the spell power has to be slotted on equipment, taking up slots and they do not scale with all the prr debuffs flying around. Vile Chemist is only a few paltry damage tiers, and at level 12 it's 4d8 poison dice + around 15~ doubleshot in the tree total, for dps increases.
11 rogue by itself is 6d6 sneak dice that scale with 150% of your ranged power, which you want to gear for anyway ( and it reaches insane rp amounts boosted ), unlike nullification items. 10% more fort bypass for sharn.
The 3 bard levels alone are probably 10% higher than an alchemist split when counting First Chord. Check your damage value on the 11/6/3 then see the numbers when something is fully debuffed.
I'll admit the Through the Mists swap wasn't accounted for. There's probably a few other things I've missed as well. Price of coming back to the game after so long away.
However, you did miss a few dps boosts from alchemist. Having trance and your damage mod all key off the same ability, does make up for some of this. Further, you have built in tenser's, as well as, stupid levels of being tanky (for making use of archers focus more). There's a lot of little things that add up. A lot of people really underestimate how much survivability boosts can up your overall dps simply because you can pull off more risky shit.
I'll definitely play through some more content with both to see where they stand. I agree with you that the alchy split is less dps, I'm just not sure I'd concede more than 12% dps without a detailed breakdown / playthrough. There's also a lot of utility from the alchy spells (theres a few things that are broken, some bad, some very very good).
Idk I rolled both builds because devs were taking too long to put lamma up. Going to keep playing both till lamma gets posted, and then I'll probably settle on one.