WonderfulFoppyBint wrote on May 25
th, 2015 at 12:57pm:
Oli would you humor me---what is the rate of fire on a great crossbow? Maybe I missed a thread with that info in here, I don't have a repeater build atm or I would check the rate of fire on a Great Crossbow. Hence why I asked in my previous post. Amyway... I'll show what I'm looking at:
The rate of fire for great crossbow I have is 80* shots per 60s. Repeaters do 54 volleys per 60s. At ~4 bolts per volley (repeater) and 1.4 bolts per shot (great crossbow) that comes out to:
216 vs 112 bolts per minute
Am not concerned about threat changes / vorpal knockdown / some sneak attack when I'm getting almost double the hits
Edit: Text in Red - Dont account for doubleshot. At least not to start. Ill add it below if you desire however
Alright, your getting 80 shots per minute on Gbow, and 54 volleys (54*3=162) shots per minute on a repeater. Lets Math
Assuming both bows are exactly the same, just ones a repeater (heavy) and the others a gbow.. Greensteel blanks work for this.
Full Mechanic tree gives: (Assuming lvl 20 rogue)
Sharpshooter - +7 dmg to Repeaters, +14 to Gbows + 5d6 SA
Sniper - 1d6 SA to repeaters, 2d6 SA + 1W to Gbows
Expert Builder - +1 Crit Multi for repeaters, +2 for Gbows
Hipflask - +1 Repeaters, +2 Gbows + 2d6 SA
Base 10d6 SA from rogue levels
Heavy GS Repeater - 1.50 [1d10] + 5
Adding in the above to repeater equation we get: 1.50[1d10] +13 +11d6SA
Comes to: 15-28 + 11-66 SA
Due to the volley, this comes to 45-84.
Greatbow - 1.50 [2d8] + 5
Once again, add from above: 2.50 [2d8] + 21 + 19d6 SA
Comes to: 26-41 + 19-114 SA
With the numbers youve given on shots per minute:
Repeaters - 162(15-28) = 2430-4536
Gbows - 80(26-41) = 2080-3280
These numbers assume absolutly no crits and no Sneak attacks.
Now lets account for Crits, with the same shots per minute. Gbow has a 18-20, Repeater 19-20 assuming you took the feat we get 15-20(30%) on Gbow, and 17-20(20%) on Repeater.
80*30%= 24 of the 80 shots crit on Gbow
162*20%=32.4 of the 162 shots crit on Repeater
Repeaters new min-max: 3420-6384
Gbows new min-max: 3952-6232
So as you can see, the greatbows low-end dmg now exceeds that of the repeater, even with repeaters doing twice as manyshots. Repeater top end dmg however is currently better, but not by much. Now lets run the numbers for Sneak attacks, without crits.
There are many skills and passives that improve the chance to land sneak attacks, so we will assume they all land as SA.
26-94 dmg on repeaters
45-155 dmg on Gbows
Over the 80 shots on Gbow: 3600-12400
162 Shots on Repeater: 4212-15228
Including Crits + SA, we get:
Gbows: 6840-23560
Repeaters: 5928-21432
So, as you can see.. In the end, Greatbows are still better unless you can negate all Crits and Sneak Attack dmg. This is just Base dmg as well, effects that have on crit will favor the greatbow more, naturally, since it crits more.