TL;DR: Anything to do with INT in the Harper Tree produces no effect in animal form (Combat DCs untested). Same if not in animal form, but using handwraps or no weapon in hand.
Sun Elf, 9 Druid, 3 Ranger, 3 Cleric (to test whether Righteous Weapons stacks with Harper Enchantment; no points were in Cleric trees during this test.) Relevant Feats: Power Attack, Greater SWF (10 Melee Power; +50% dmg from related ability score). +2 ship buff to INT and STR. No other wpn or dmg-affecting ship buff. +5 STR item, No INT item (I used Fox's Cunning to check Harper INT to dmg): INT 26: +8 mod (30 w/Fox's: +10 mod), STR 21: +5 mod (16 w/o STR item: +3 mod) (25 w/STR item + Animal Growth: +7 mod) Kept the STR item on for all tests, unless noted. Harper Tree INT to att and INT to dmg enhancements. +6 to melee power. EDIT: Forgot about Instinctive Fighting in the Nature's Warrior tree. +2 base melee dmg in Animal Forms from that.
All tests were performed with an "unkilled" training dummy, so "helpless" didn't mess with the numbers.
Winter Wolf form
Wielding Dawnbreaker: 1.5[1d10] +3 enhancement (+4 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
Power Attack inactive - STR item: 11-22 + STR item: 13-24 (1.5[1d10] + 26, according to the inventory drop-down details. lol) + KtA: 13-24 + Fox's Cunning: 13-24 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-24 + Animal Growth: 16-26 (That's right, a +3 to the min, but only a +2 to the max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 16-26 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 16-26
PA active - STR item: 17-27 + STR item: 19-30 + KtA: 19-30 + Fox's Cunning: 19-30 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 19-30 + Animal Growth: 22-32 (Again +3 min, +2 max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 22-32 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 22-32
Wielding Dawnbreaker: 1.5[1d10] +3 enhancement (+4 with Harper Enchantment) + Burning Light (orb):1d6 +0 (Harper Enhancement does not seem to affect this). GSWF in effect.
No Change.
Wielding rangen (ML6, non-paragon) +1 club (+2 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 9-19 + STR item: 11-22 + KtA: 11-22 + Fox's Cunning: 11-22 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 11-22 + Animal Growth: 13-24 + Animal Growth +KtA: 13-24 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-24
PA active - STR item: 15-25 + STR item: 17-27 + KtA: 17-27 + Fox's Cunning: 17-27 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 17-27 + Animal Growth: 19-30 + Animal Growth +KtA: 19-30 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 19-30
+ Burning Light (orb): No Change.
Wielding no weapons. GSWF not in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 6-15 (Theory: +6 Melee power has no effect at +3 mod.) + STR item: 8-18 (Should be 8-17. +6 Melee Power's effect at +5 mod, I guess.) + KtA: 8-18 + Fox's Cunning: 8-18 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 8-18 + Animal Growth: 10-20 + Animal Growth + KtA: 10-20 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 10-20
PA active - STR item: 11-21 (Should be 11-20) + STR item: 13-23 (Should be 13-22) + KtA: 13-23 + Fox's Cunning: 13-23 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-23 + Animal Growth: 15-25 + Animal Growth +KtA: 15-25 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 15-25
+ Burning Light (orb): No Change.
Wolf Form (not Winter Wolf)
Wielding Dawnbreaker: 1.5[1d10] +3 enhancement (+4 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
Power Attack inactive - STR item: 11-17 + STR item: 13-19 + KtA: 13-19 + Fox's Cunning: 13-19 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-19 + Animal Growth: 16-22 (+3 to the min, and +3 to the max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 16-22 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 16-22
PA active - STR item: 17-23 + STR item: 19-25 + KtA: 19-25 + Fox's Cunning: 19-25 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 19-25 + Animal Growth: 22-27 (Back again to +3 min, +2 max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 22-27 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 22-27
+ Burning Light (orb): No Change.
Wielding no weapons. GSWF not in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 6-11 + STR item: 8-13 + KtA: 8-13 + Fox's Cunning: 8-13 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 8-13 + Animal Growth: 10-15 + Animal Growth + KtA: 10-15 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 10-15
PA active - STR item: 11-16 + STR item: 13-19 (should be 13-18) + KtA: 13-19 + Fox's Cunning: 13-19 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-19 + Animal Growth: 15-21 (should be 15-20) + Animal Growth +KtA: 15-21 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 15-21
+ Burning Light (orb): No Change.
Bear Form
Wielding Dawnbreaker: 1.5[1d10] +3 enhancement (+4 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
Power Attack inactive - STR item: 11-22 + STR item: 13-22 + KtA: 13-22 + Fox's Cunning: 13-22 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-22 + Animal Growth: 16-24 (Again +3 to the min, but only a +2 to the max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 16-24 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 16-24
PA active - STR item: 17-27 + STR item: 19-27 + KtA: 19-27 + Fox's Cunning: 19-27 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 19-27 + Animal Growth: 22-30 (+3 min, +3 max) + Animal Growth +KtA: 22-30 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 22-30
Wielding no weapons. GSWF not in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 6-13 + STR item: 8-15 + KtA: 8-15 + Fox's Cunning: 8-15 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 8-15 + Animal Growth: 10-18 (should be 10-17) + Animal Growth + KtA: 10-18 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 10-18
PA active - STR item: 11-19 (should be 11-18) + STR item: 13-21 (should be 13-20) + KtA: 13-21 + Fox's Cunning: 13-21 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 13-21 + Animal Growth: 15-23 (should be 15-22) + Animal Growth +KtA: 15-23 + Animal Growth + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 15-23
[I sort of haphazardly checked Ram's Might here and there; it added +2 dmg (+3 total, when animal growth was not active), as expected. Testing could certainly be more thorough, though.]
Sun Elf (no Animal Form) INT 28: +9 mod (32 w/Fox's: +11 mod), STR same as in other tests
Wielding Dawnbreaker: 1.5[1d10] +3 enhancement (+4 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
Power Attack inactive - STR item: 26-42 - STR item, +KtA: 31-47 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 31-47 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 37-53 + STR item: 26-42 + KtA: 31-47 + Fox's Cunning: 31-47 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 37-53 + Animal Growth: (can't be cast on non-animal forms)
PA active - STR item: 32-48 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 37-53 - STR item, + KtA: 37-53 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 42-59 + STR item: 32-48 + KtA: 37-53 + Fox's Cunning: 37-53 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 42-59
+ Burning Light (orb): No Change.
Wielding rangen (ML6, non-paragon) +1 club (+2 with Harper Enchantment). GSWF in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 24-30 - STR item, + KtA: 29-34 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 29-34 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 34-40 + STR item: 24-30 + KtA: 29-34 + Fox's Cunning: 29-34 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 34-40
PA active - STR item: 30-35 - STR item, + KtA: 34-40 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 34-40 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 40-46 + STR item: 30-35 + KtA: 34-40 + Fox's Cunning: 34-40 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 40-46
+ Burning Light (orb): No change.
Wielding no weapons. GSWF not in effect.
PA inactive - STR item: 4-6 - STR item, + KtA: 4-6 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 4-6 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 4-6 + STR item: 6-8 + KtA: 6-8 + Fox's Cunning: 6-8 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 6-8
PA active - STR item: 9-11 - STR item, + KtA: 9-11 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 9-11 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 9-11 + STR item: 11-13 + KtA: 11-13 + Fox's Cunning: 11-13 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 11-13
Unarmed + Burning Light (orb): This shield bashes with the orb, doing force damage. The orb would do INT dmg without Harper enhancements.
PA inactive - STR item: 10-15 - STR item, + KtA: 14-20 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 12-18 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 18-23 + STR item: 10-15 + KtA: 14-20 + Fox's Cunning: 12-18 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 18-23
PA active - STR item: 15-21 - STR item, + KtA: 20-25 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning: 18-23 - STR item, + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 23-28 + STR item: 15-21 + KtA: 20-25 + Fox's Cunning: 18-23 + Fox's Cunning + KtA: 23-28
ADDENDUM: I got a pair of +2 handwraps to my test druid. Apart from the +2, there was no difference between the wraps and weaponless. This doesn't rule out strange effects if Monk levels are present, of course.
|