5 Foot Step wrote on Jan 17
th, 2015 at 1:00am:
No.
If there were a x4 two-hander for Barbarians then you would be correct, but there's not. Picks have the highest base DPS when you expand the crit range that much, add that in with all the effects that double on offhand and THF gets left behind. (Remember I'm only talking about Barbarians in this thread.)
With rage extended crit and imp crit (as well as devestating crit and oc) a pick gives you 1-16x1,17-18x4, 19-20x7 (total of 38).
Maul (with all of the above and pulverize) is 1-14x1, 15-18x3, 19-20x6 (total 38)
So crit profile equales out however THF uses 1.5 str mod on all attacks while TWF uses x1 str on main hand and x0.5 str on off hand.
Thf can get up to 35% chance to proc special effects on glancing blows and up to 79% damage.
Considering attack speed while twitch fighting thf is real close if not over twf attack per second.
Check out this video's end fight at
http://youtu.be/UTwsPPtf2ow The guy is thf till trash is dead then he twitchs the boss (whom's hp is dropping really fast).
Easy enough to test, you can go in there and compare dps on the boss like you did vs the tree build in vol.
Video seems to be before the nerf though if you activate your eye just for the end fight the difference shouldn't be that great in your favor (because of the +10 melle power).
I'd be interested to see what you come up with.