5 Foot Step wrote on Jul 19
th, 2015 at 12:22am:
Your lack of actual testing is showing.
Sting reticks on every crit. So once fully stacked it deals an extra 20d4x2 (100 average) on 80% of your attacks if your build crits on a 5...plus it continues as a DoT if you stop attacking for some reason.
Good damage, yes?
Every 3 seconds...right? Or you mean it does 100 damage on every crit at 20 stacks?
Even if it does do 80 damage a star (crit on a 5) you would have to be using Shadowstar, which means you would lose all of the Thunderforged on hit procs, which are 83 on their own (33 Touch of Flames, 14 Dragons Edge, 36 Mortal Fear, not to mention 5.88 for Meteoric Star), so you're down on proc damage, but obviously ahead on crit damage. Though with a TF you would be critting on a 13, not a 5, so you're getting 45% more crit damage with the shadowstar, albiet at a slightly lower base damage (TF +11, more [W]s).
I could see on a boss where this is would make Shadowstar shine so much (Or I guess any Keen Shuriken),but really it's only worth it with a keen shuriken, and on anthing you can 100% of the time bypass the fort of.
Against trash, I think a TF would still be a better choice because of Mortal Fear, but I haven't actually done the math